From Darkness To Light

21 Nov 2026

Colorado Court of Appeals reverses judgement against former City of Durango volunteer

Posted by Adam Howell


The Colorado Court of Appeals vacated a judgement by a District Court in a case that was brought by Durango City Attorney Mark Morgan against a former volunteer board member.

Durango City Attorney Mark Morgan

Durango City Attorney Mark Morgan.

Former Infrastructure Advisory Board member John Simpson was relieved to find out that Mark Morgan was a legal loser once again.

City Attorney Mark Morgan sought a declaratory judgement from the District Court saying the following about Simpson:

  1. He violated Colorado’s Open Records Act (CORA) by failing to release emails
  2. He violated CORA by writing “not subject to CORA” at the bottom of his emails
  3. His emails were public records subject to CORA
  4. His use of “Not subject to CORA” at the bottom of his emails had no legal affect

Originally, the District Court ruled that:

the emails were public records subject to CORA and that Simpson violated CORA by withholding two of them. The court dismissed the request for a declaration that Simpson violated CORA purely by including the “not subject to CORA” language in his emails. It also declined to declare that the Board of Ethics had jurisdiction to address the alleged CORA violations, noting that the Board had not yet even determined the scope of its jurisdiction, so that issue was not ripe for review.

Basically, the Court of Appeals said that the City failed to exhaust all of its administrative remedies prior to filing the lawsuit against Simpson. This, because the city had not allowed the Board of Ethics to make a determination as to whether Simpson had done what the city had accused him of.

As such, the District Court had no jurisdiction in the City’s lawsuit against Simpson, the Court of Appeals opinion said.

The victory for Simpson marked the second time in November 2026 that legal loser Mark Morgan lost a case in court for the City of Durango.

Earlier this month, for instance, City Attorney Mark Morgan lost a lawsuit for the City of Durango in District Court. A judge ruled that the City of Durango veered from what voters authorized in ballot language about how it planned on spending city bond money to demolish an arts and science annex building so that it could build a new police station.

Basically, the City tried to lie to the residents about what they had voted on, which was really only about restoring two existing buildings for a city hall and police station.

Adam Howell is a writer who believes in free press and the importance of the constitution. He can be reached by clicking on this link to the contact page.


Leave a Reply

Message: